Bright Foster City–style living and dining room with pale walls, oak furniture and winter sunlight overlooking a green backyard.

How to Read Foster City Home Prices This Winter

November 19, 2026

In October 2026, the median single-family sale price in Foster City was $2,702,500. In October 2025 it was $1,965,000. That is a 37.5 percent gain in twelve months, and it is the figure a portal or a neighbor would quote you. Over the same two Octobers, the median price per square foot went from $1,095 to $1,112, a gain of about 1.6 percent.

Both numbers come from the San Mateo County Association of Realtors monthly reports, which use MLSListings data. The gap between them comes from the size of the houses that sold. The six homes that closed in Foster City in October 2026 averaged 2,398 square feet. The eleven that closed in October 2025 averaged 1,973. October's median went up because bigger houses sold that month. The price of a Foster City house, per foot, held about where it was.

In a city this size, the monthly median mostly tells you which houses sold, and price per square foot is the better gauge of what a house is worth.

Why one month here can mislead you

In calendar year 2025, 103 single-family homes sold in Foster City, at a median of $2,200,000 and $1,130 per square foot, according to the SAMCAR 2025 annual report. That averages out to fewer than nine closings a month. In some months there were far fewer. November 2025 had 2 sales and April 2026 had 2. With two sales, the median is the midpoint of those two prices, so one unusually large or small home can move it by several hundred thousand dollars.

San Mateo works differently. In October 2026, 42 single-family homes sold in the city of San Mateo, at a median of $2,375,500. With seven times as many closings, a single sale has much less effect on the median. In October, Foster City's median came in about $327,000 above San Mateo's. Anyone comparing the two cities on that number alone would think Foster City is the pricier market, when what actually differed was the size of the houses that sold there that month.

Thirteen months of Foster City medians

Here is every monthly SAMCAR single-family report for Foster City from October 2025 through October 2026. Read down the median column and then down the price-per-square-foot column.

Month Homes sold Median sale price Median $/sq ft Avg home size (sq ft)
Oct 2025 11 $1,965,000 $1,095 1,973
Nov 2025 2 $2,315,000 $1,213 1,935
Dec 2025 5 $2,195,000 $1,048 2,102
Jan 2026 3 $2,400,000 $1,195 2,036
Feb 2026 6 $2,741,944 $1,093 2,183
Mar 2026 10 $2,247,713 $1,064 2,039
Apr 2026 2 $2,475,000 $1,045 2,365
May 2026 7 $2,200,000 $1,095 2,072
Jun 2026 7 $2,161,250 $1,129 2,035
Jul 2026 8 $2,122,500 $1,142 1,870
Aug 2026 11 $2,050,000 $1,048 2,012
Sep 2026 4 $2,562,000 $1,073 2,219
Oct 2026 6 $2,702,500 $1,112 2,398

The median ranged from $1,965,000 to $2,741,944, a spread of almost $777,000. Price per square foot ranged from $1,045 to $1,213, and in eleven of the thirteen months it was between $1,045 and $1,142.

The two highest medians are February 2026 and October 2026, and both were months when larger homes sold. February's median was $2,741,944 with average size up at 2,183 square feet, yet its $1,093 per foot was slightly below October 2025's $1,095. The lowest median, $1,965,000 in October 2025, came in a month when the homes sold averaged under 2,000 square feet. In each case, the size of the homes sold explains most of the movement in the median.

The quarterly report shows the same thing. For the third quarter of 2026, July through September, 23 Foster City homes sold at a median of $2,170,000 and $1,063 per square foot. Three months of sales together give a steadier read than any one of those months alone.

Why price per foot works well in Foster City

Price per square foot is a weak yardstick in a town where homes of very different ages sit on very different lots. Foster City's housing came from one plan. The City of Foster City's community profile records that T. Jack Foster prepared the master plan for Brewer Island, that the County approved it in 1961, and that ground was broken that August. It also records that 200 families had moved in by the end of 1964, that the population reached 5,000 by 1966, and that the plan laid the city out in numbered residential neighborhoods.

A city built from one plan over a short period ends up with fairly similar lots. Foster City's single-family homes that sold in 2025 averaged 2,042 square feet of living space on 6,038-square-foot lots. When houses are that alike, dividing price by size gives you a figure you can actually compare from one sale to the next.

Price per foot has one limit, and the table shows it. The month with the smallest homes and the month with some of the largest sit at opposite ends of the range. November 2025's two sales averaged 1,935 square feet and came in at $1,213 per foot, the highest in the table. April 2026's two sales averaged 2,365 square feet and came in at $1,045, the lowest. When you look at a Foster City listing, compare its price per foot with recent sales of similar size. Comparing it with the citywide figure is less reliable.

Supply has stayed tight all year

Price per square foot shows that values held steady. The supply numbers show how competitive buying a Foster City house was over the year. Months of inventory measures how long the current listings would last at the current sales pace. For Foster City it was between 0.4 and 2.1 in every month from October 2025 through October 2026. In October 2026 the city had 11 new listings, 5 homes in active inventory, and 0.7 months of supply.

Buyers paid more than the asking price in twelve of those thirteen months. The share of list price received ran from 103 percent to 109 percent, and the one exception was January 2026, at 99 percent. In October 2026 it was 107 percent.

That pattern describes a market where asking prices are set below where the homes will sell and buyers bid them up. Price per square foot shows that the level buyers bid up to has stayed fairly steady.

What last winter suggests for this one

With the winter months still ahead, last winter is the closest guide. Foster City recorded 2 single-family sales in November 2025, 5 in December 2025, and 3 in January 2026. That is ten closings over three months.

Fewer sales did not make those months easier for buyers. December 2025 homes sold at 109 percent of list, the highest of the year, at $1,048 per square foot. January 2026 was the one month buyers paid under asking, at 99 percent, with homes averaging 27 days on market. Three January sales is too few to call it a pattern. The real lesson from last winter is that there were very few homes to choose from. Anyone searching between now and the end of January may see only a few houses that fit, and each one is a single data point.

The medians that come out over the winter will rest on a handful of sales. If December's median comes in well above or below October's $2,702,500, check the price per square foot and the average home size before deciding the market has moved. If price per foot is still between roughly $1,045 and $1,215, the median moved because of which homes sold.

How this compares with nearby cities

Price per square foot also makes cross-city comparisons fairer. In October 2026, Redwood Shores had 4 single-family sales at a median of $3,065,658 and 108 percent of list. San Mateo had 42 sales at a median of $2,375,500 with 1.2 months of supply. Foster City's 0.7 months of supply was tighter than San Mateo's that month, and Foster City homes have sold above asking in almost every month. Its medians, though, come from a much smaller set of sales. If you are choosing among these cities, compare price per square foot and months of supply. October's medians mostly show which homes happened to sell.

If you are deciding between a house and an attached home, the city's other housing types are covered in condo and townhome living in Foster City. The day-to-day side of the lagoons is covered in waterfront living in Foster City. More on the city is on the Foster City neighborhood page.

If you own a home in Foster City and want to know where it sits on that per-square-foot range, Caitlin Beanan can prepare a free home valuation that compares your house with recent sales of similar size, not just the citywide median. If you are buying this winter, reach out and we will review each new Foster City listing against the sales that matter most for that house.

Work With Caitlin

Looking to buy, sell, or just have a question? I'm always available to help and would love to work with you. Contact me today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!